Saturday, January 2, 2010


Glenn Greenwald Reminds Us That Terrorism Wasn't Invented on 9/11

Glenn Greenwald takes Jeffrey Weiss to task over perpetuating the stereotype that terrorism is a thing that Muslims do. Here's what Weiss wrote that set off GG:
And we're still left with a terrible problem for a free and multicultural society: Even though 99.999 percent of Muslims abhor attacks on innocent civilians on moral and theological grounds, 100 percent of attempted terrorist attacks on the U.S. (and, with the exception of the Basques in Spain, terrorists attacks on all Western nations) since the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing have been committed by people claiming to act in the name of Islam.
I must confess, even though I knew GG was getting ready to list a bunch of counterexamples, they weren't popping into my head until he listed them for me. In other words, I have been successfully conditioned into only considering a bombing or shooting as "terrorism" if it's carried out by Islamist radicals who hate the U.S. I'm not saying I consciously articulated it that way, but it's the only explanation I have for why Weiss' claims didn't make me immediately think of:

* The IRA's terrorist acts.

* The anthrax attacks on US soil that (at least "officially") were carried out by a white guy.

* The bombings of abortion clinics / shooting abortionists on U.S. soil by Christians (I assume).

GG also lists terrorist acts committed by non-Muslims in other countries, but I'm not embarrassed that they didn't occur to me.

Now part of what's going on psychologically, I think, isn't merely racism or being brainwashed by Fox News' foreign policy agenda. No, I don't feel worried about guys shooting abortionists, because I'm not an abortionist. I don't get anxious about IRA terrorists, because I don't plan on taking a bus in Ireland anytime soon. Etc. And I'm also not too worried about the political response to such crimes, because they will lead to things like spying on militia groups which is bad but not nearly as bad as federalizing airport security.

In contrast, I do worry about Muslim terrorists deciding to start sending suicide bombers into U.S. shopping malls. That really would completely alter my lifestyle, even if only a handful of people died and I didn't know any of them. First of all it would justify all sorts of government power grabs, and second of all it would really be a bummer if you couldn't go to the mall without worrying about getting blown up.

Note to new readers: I am hugely opposed to US foreign policy. The above might sound as if I'm wondering how "we can win the war on terror" when that's not it at all. I am also not excusing or downplaying people who murder abortion doctors. I'm just trying to be honest with myself about why Weiss' demonstrably and obviously false claims at first sounded OK to me.

Your point about shopping malls raises something I was talking with a friend about following the Christmas Day air plot - namely why do these guys target planes so obsessively?

Given the amount of security at airports you'd think they's follow an easier strategy. The only reasons I could come up with were that the number of potential terrorists is tiny, they are attracted by the drama of a plan bombing, and/or they are not particularly bright. Any thoughts?

If you've ever seen Jackie Chan's phenomenal Police Story 2 you'd reconsider just how dramatic and destructive a mall bombing can be!
I think terrorist acts are a real threat, but not nearly as much as what the current statist thinkers think exists. It's real, yes, but it has been blown out of proportion to what current policy is.

And really, the fact is, you can never be completely safe but no one accepts that and engage in what's going on now, which is mostly just security theater.

J Cortez
This is a dishonest red herring, Bob. You shouldn't fall for that argument. I'm anti-war as well, but if one is against US government actions, does not mean one should automatically start excusing/minimizing USGs enemies actions.
IRA was localized to Ireland, Basque to Spain etc etc.
Whereas, Islamic jihadist terrorism is affecting people in India, Indonesia, England, France, Morocco, Saudi, Yemen, Pakistan, China, Thailand, Nigeria, Somalia, Turkey, Israel, Philippines etc etc.
Infact, if you ditch the stupid American news-sphere for a change (including blogs), and just delve into purely what all the different Muslim terrorist groups THEMSELVES SAY, you will see the connection. Whether they are philipino, pakistani, or british, All groups share similar goals globalized to the whole world.
Lets not put another set of blinkers when see take off one
Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]